Transgender  Bisexual  Lesbian  Gay  LGBTQ+ Movement 

Supreme Court gives federal job protections to LGBTQ+ workers

Nimisha Jun 15

Supreme Court gives federal job protections to LGBTQ+ workers

The Supreme Court, in a divided bench decision ruled that federal law dealing with sex discrimination protects LGBTQ+ workers from job discrimination, a landmark decision that gives the community a new set of civil rights.

The Supreme Court, in a divided bench decision ruled that federal law dealing with sex discrimination protects LGBTQ+ workers from job discrimination, a landmark decision that gives the community a new set of civil rights.

This comes two days after the Trump administration removed trans rights protections in healthcare, and defined sex as biologically assigned sex or gender.

The judgement

The judgement, written by Associate Justice Neil Gorsuch, President Donald Trump's first nominee to the court, was also contributed to by Chief Justice John Roberts and the court's four liberal justices. Associate Justices Samuel Alito, Clarence Thomas and Brett Kavanaugh dissented. This put the majority to 6-3.

Among the notable points of the judgement is, "An employer who fires an individual for being homosexual or transgender fires that person for traits or actions it would not have questioned in members of a different sex".

And further, "We do not hesitate to recognize today a necessary consequence of that legislative choice: An employer who fires an individual merely for being gay or transgender defies the law."

Gorsuch wrote that "the 1964 Civil Rights Act might not have anticipated their work would lead to this particular result.” But he said the language of the law, which bars discrimination on the basis of “sex” but doesn’t explicitly mention gender identity or sexual orientation, was pretty much explicable.

He further wrote, “The limits of the drafters’ imagination supply no reason to ignore the law’s demands. Only the written word is the law, and all persons are entitled to its benefit.”

The impact of the Judgement

The judgement was the consequence of three cases, filed by two gay men and a transgender woman, from Georgia, New York and Michigan.

With more than half the U.S. states not covering sexual orientation and gender identity through their own anti-discrimination laws, and half the nation’s 8 million LGBT workers living in those states, the judgement could have a monumental impact.

It is also to be seen what happens in the context of interpretation of sex discrimination in Healthcare sector by Trump administration, since this judgement paves way for a diverse interpretation of what discrimination on the basis of sex can mean.

This can lead to a stiff challenge to Trump administration's rule in court.


Photo by Sharon McCutcheon on Unsplash


Share:


Explore sexual wellbeing

Join our email list to receive our top stories and the best podcasts in sexual wellbeing from around the world.


Similar Stories

Episode 6: S is for Sexting!

Professor Sex, Feb 19 2020

None

None

Glasses of Desire

Jennifer Beman, Aug 22

Each person's level of sexual preference is, valid. Desire discrepancy is a clinical-sounding way to say that one person in a relationship wants sex more often than the other.

Each person's level of sexual preference is, valid.

Mental Health - Talk to someone and seek help

Shakun, Jun 14

He felt irritable, wasn’t eating well and was keeping to himself, he still smiled at passersby and a...

He felt irritable, wasn’t eating well and was keep...

Tips to become an excellent lover

Avril Louise Clarke, Aug 23

How many of you have ever wondered if you’re a good lover or a bad one? What does it mean to be a g...

How many of you have ever wondered if you’re a goo...

Redefining Masculinity to Build a Better Man

Ray Motta, Nov 22 2019

Learn to reclaim masculinity by making it truly toxin-free with Ray Motta.

Learn to reclaim masculinity by making it truly toxin-free with Ray Motta.

Coming Out: planning ahead, testing the waters, environment, support systems, and safety.

Vyom Raisurana, Oct 17

Coming out of the closet can be an intimidating and daunting process for many. Hiding or lying about one’s identity can be a very frustrating experience.

Coming out of the closet can be an intimidating and daunting process for many.

Discover by Sexuality

Gay

Lesbian

Bisexual

Transgender

Questioning

Heterosexual

or discover by topic

Sex, Media & Culture

Singlehood

Relationships

LGBTQ+ Movement

Mental Health

Reworking Relationships

Divorce and Separation

Ageing

Sex & Sex Education

Sexual Health

Sexuality Studies